[ROLL CALL]
[00:00:04]
AND THANK YOU FOR JOINING US FOR TONIGHT'S PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION MEETING.
WE'LL HAVE THE ROLL CALL, MR. HOGAN CHAIRMAN WASHINGTON, PRESIDENT VICE CHAIRMAN GROUT, PRESENT COMMISSIONER ADDISON, PRESENT COMMISSIONER ALLEN PRESENT COMMISSIONER COLLINS, LEWIS COMMISSIONER, ELEANOR COMMISSIONER HAWTHORNE, PRESIDENT COMMISSIONER HILL PRESENT AND COMMISSIONER STERLING.
THANK YOU, MR. HOGAN AT THIS AT THIS
[APPROVAL OF MINUTES]
TIME, WE'LL MOVE ON TO THE APPROVAL OF THE MINUTES.IS THERE A MOTION TO APPROVE THE MINUTES OF THE OCTOBER 19TH MEETING MOTION BY COMMISSIONER ADDISON SECOND BY COMMISSIONER HILL? OR ARE THERE ANY OBJECTIONS TO APPROVING THE MINUTES? SAY NONE OF THOSE, THESE ITEMS HAVE NOT BEEN APPROVED AT THIS
[RULES FOR CONDUCTING PUBLIC HEARINGS]
TIME.I'LL ASK THE VICE CHAIRMAN AND READING THE RULES FOR CONDUCTING PUBLIC HEARINGS RULES FOR CONDUCTING PUBLIC HEARINGS, MAIL OR SUBMITTED PUBLIC COMMENTS WILL NO LONGER BE READ ALOUD DURING THE PUBLIC COMMENT PERIOD FOR EACH ITEM ON THE AGENDA AND INTERESTED MEMBER OF THE PUBLIC WHO WISHES TO COMMENT ON ANY ITEM IN THE AGENDA MAY COMMENT IN PERSON AT THE RIVER CENTER BRANCH LIBRARY AT TWO 15 NORTH BOULEVARD, BATON ROUGE, LOUISIANA SEVEN OH EIGHT OH TWO FOURTH FLOOR MEETING ROOM.
DURING THE MEETING, ALL PERSONS ENTERING THE LIBRARY MUST WEAR A MASK.
ALL COMMENTS WILL BE STREAMED LIVE TO THE METROPOLITAN COUNCIL, CHAMBERS AND BROADCAST WWW DOT
IT'LL THE BATON ROUGE PARISH AND THE CITY OF BATON ROUGE PARISH OF EAST BATON ROUGE.
FACEBOOK PAGE VIA FACEBOOK LIVE.
THE PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING WILL ALSO BE STREAMED LIVE TO THE RIVER CENTER.
BRANCH LIBRARY MEETING ROOM COMMENTS SUBMITTED PRIOR TO 4:00 PM ON THE MEETING.
DATE WILL BE COMPILED BY POSITION FOR OR AGAINST.
AND THE TOTAL NUMBER WILL BE ANNOUNCED BEFORE THE ITEMS, PUBLIC HEARING ANY INTERESTED IN ANY INTERESTED PERSON WHO DOES NOT WISH TO COMMENT IN PERSON MAY USE A FORM FOUND@WWWDOTPRLA.GOV.
PC COMMENTS SUBMITTED BY EMAIL FORM TO THE COMMISSION.
MEMBERS WILL NOT BE READ ALOUD AT THE MEETING.
APPLICANTS AND APPLICANTS REPRESENTATIVES FOR PROPOSAL WILL SPEAK FIRST FOR A PERIOD, NOT TO EXCEED 15 MINUTES.
THOSE MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC DESIRE AND TO SPEAK ON A PARTICULAR ITEM SHOULD REFER TO A MEETING AGENDA AND FILL OUT A REQUEST TO SPEAK FOR THEM.
ONCE THE ITEM IS ANNOUNCED, EACH PERSON'S NAME WHO HAS FILLED OUT THE FORM WILL BE CALLED ON TO SPEAK.
THEN THE OPPONENTS, EACH SPEAKER WILL, WILL NOT BE ALLOWED MORE THAN THREE MINUTES.
SPEAKERS ARE REQUESTED TO LIMIT THEIR REMARKS AND TO AVOID DUPLICATION OF THEIR PRESENTATIONS.
APPLICANT WILL BE ALLOWED A TOTAL OF FIVE MINUTES FOR REBUTTAL.
THANK YOU, VICE CHAIRMAN GROUT COMMISSIONER MEMBERS.
[CONSENT AGENDA]
TIME, WE CAN MOVE ON TO THE CONSENT AGENDA.MR. MORRIS, THE FOLLOWING ITEMS ARE ON THE CONSENT AGENDA FOR WITHDRAWAL ITEM NUMBER TWO, PA 1721 FIVE FOUR SIX FIVE YEARS ROAD TO AMEND THE COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE PLAN FROM AGRICULTURAL RURAL TO COMMERCIAL ON PROPERTY LOCATED ON THE NORTH SIDE, APPEARS ROAD TO THE WEST OF LIBERTY ROAD, WITHDRAWN BY THE APPLICANT ON NOVEMBER.
THE THIRD ITEM NUMBER THREE, KS 44 21 FIVE 46 FIVE PEERS ROAD TO REZONE FROM RURAL TO LIVE COMMERCIAL ONE LLC.
ONE ON PROPERTY LOCATED ON THE NORTH SIDE OF PIERCE ROAD TO THE WEST OF LIBERTY ROAD.
ALSO WITHDRAWN BY THE APPLICANT ON NOVEMBER THE THIRD ITEM NUMBER FOUR, PA 1829, 15 STARRING LANE TO AMEND THE COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE PLAN FROM RESIDENTIAL NEIGHBOR TO COMPACT NEIGHBORHOOD ON PROPERTY LOCATED ON THE WEST SIDE OF STARRING LANE, SOUTH OF CHANDLER DRIVE WITHDRAWN BY THE APPLICANT ON NOVEMBER THE FIFTH AND ITEM NUMBER 14, I SPOT 1119 ROSA REVISION ONE PROPOSED MIXED USE DEVELOPMENT, INCLUDING COMMERCIAL OFFICE RETAIL RESTAURANT IN MEDIUM DENSITY.
RESIDENTIAL USES ON PROPERTY LOCATED ON THE NORTH SIDE OF HIGHLAND ROAD, WEST OF KENILWORTH PARKWAY IN SOUTH OF MENLO DRIVE WITHDRAWN BY THE APPLICANT ON NOVEMBER THE THIRD AND THE FOLLOWING ITEMS ARE ON THE CONSENT AGENDA FOR DEFERRAL ITEM NUMBER FIVE, BUT THREE 20 FIELDSTONE CROSSING DEFER TO DECEMBER 14TH, FIVE COUNCIL MEMBER ROCCA ITEM NUMBER NINE, CASE 54 DASH 2062 63 CO MEET DR.
[00:05:01]
SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL, A ONE IN HEAVY COMMERCIAL SEAT, TWO TO RURAL ON PROPERTY LOCATED ON THE NORTH SIDE OF COLUMBIA DRIVE EAST OF PLANK ROAD DEFERRED TO DECEMBER THE 14TH BY COUNCIL MEMBER BANKS.I HAVE A NUMBER 1905 DASH ZERO FOUR BURBANK PARK TOWNHOMES PELICAN LAKES, FINAL DEVELOPMENT PLAN PROPOSED MEDIUM DENSITY, SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL USE ON PROPERTY LOCATED ON THE WEST SIDE OF BURBANK DRIVE AND SOUTH OF PELICAN LAKES PARKWAY.
THE FIRST TO DECEMBER THE 14TH BY THE PLANNING DIRECTOR ITEM NUMBER 26 S P SIX DASH 20, THE BEND ON BLUE BONNET PROPOSED MULTIFAMILY APARTMENTS LOCATED EAST OF BLUEBONNET AND SOUTH OF BURBANK DRIVE DEFERRED TO DECEMBER THE 14TH COUNCIL COUNCIL MEMBER LOOP.
THE FOLLOWING ITEMS ARE ON THE CONSENT AGENDA FOR APPROVAL ITEM NUMBER EIGHT, CASE 53 DASH 2121 SIX SEVEN CORSI BOULEVARD.
THE REASON FROM RURAL TO LIGHT COMMERCIAL, ONE LC ONE ON PROPERTY LOCATED ON THE NORTH SIDE.
OF COURSE HE BOULEVARD EAST OF LAKE LAUREN'S DRIVE ITEM NUMBER 10, CASE 55 21 SEVEN ONE SEVEN NORTH RIVER ROAD TO REASON FROM COMMERCIAL GAIN CG BUSINESS C5 PLAN, YET DEVELOPMENT, PUD, AND HEAVY INDUSTRIAL INTO TWO COMMERCIAL GAMING CG ON PROPERTY LOCATED ON THE WEST SIDE.
NO, I HAVE NORTH RIVER ROAD NORTH OF NORTH STREET, ITEM NUMBER 11, CASE 57 DASH 20.
SO 72 31 INNOVATION PARK DRIVE TO REZONE FROM RURAL TO AN COMMERCIAL ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE BAR AND LOUNGE CAV TWO TO ZERO LOT LINE EIGHT, 2.6 ON PROPERTY LOCATED NORTH OF INNOVATION PARK DRIVE IN EAST OF NICHOLSON.
NUMBER 12 IS FIVE DASH 20 RIVER HILLS FARM PROPOSED LOW DENSITY, RESIDENTIAL SUBDIVISION LOCATED NORTH OF INNOVATION PARK DRIVE IN THE EAST OF NICHOLSON AND DR.
IVAN 13 CASE 58, 2021 ONE ONE LOB DEL BOULEVARD IN 5,100 GREENLAND SPRINGS ROAD TO RESIGN FROM LIMITED RESIDENTIAL, A 3.1 TO LIGHT COMMERCIAL THREE THREE ON PROPERTY LOCATED ON THE SOUTH SIDE OF GREENLAND HE'S ROAD WEST OF NORTH RD WOULD DROP IT.
I HAD A NUMBER 16, I SPED TWO DASH 19 EIGHT VC REVISION ONE TO REVISE THE ETERNAL INTERNAL LOT LINE CONFIGURATION TO REFLECT A COMBINATION OF LAW OR LOT.
48, A AND 42, A AND AN EXCHANGE OF PROPERTY FOR LOTS 48, A AND 48 B ON PROPERTY LOCATED ON THE NORTH SIDE OF GOODWOOD AVENUE, EAST OF H E A DAHLIA LANE, SOUTH OF GOOD LEAF WAY IN EAST OF GOODRICH ITEM NUMBER 17.
TWO DASH ZERO, ZERO LATE VILLAS CROSSING BURBANK UNIVERSITY FINAL DEVELOPMENT PLAN PROPOSED MEDIUM DENSITY, SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL USE ON PROPERTY LOCATED ON THE NORTH SIDE HAVE BEEN HER ROAD AND SOUTH OF WESLEY DRIVE ITEM NUMBER 18, PUT TWO DASH ZERO ZERO NICHOLSON TOWNHOMES BURBANK UNIVERSITY FINAL DEVELOPMENT PLAN PROPOSED MEDIUM DENSITY, SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTIAL USE ON PROPERTY LOCATED ON THE EAST SIDE OF NICHOLSON ROAD IN NORTH HAVE BEEN HEARD BURNT IN HER ROOM ITEM NUMBER 20, BUT ONE DASH 11 PHASE ONE PART ONE AND TWO POINT MARIE FINAL DEVELOPMENT PLAN REVISION EIGHT PROPOSED POOL AREA AMENITIES REVISED PRIVATE STREET WITH LOT SIZES.
NUMBER OF PARKING SPACES AND PHASE ONE BOUNDARIES LOCATED SOUTHWEST OF NICHOLSON ROAD, NORTH OF RIVER ROAD ITEM 22 S S 1320 CD TURNER PROPOSED SUBDIVISION LOCATED
[00:10:01]
NORTH OF GREENVILLE SPRINGS OR HUDSON ROAD IN WEST OF SHADY LANE.ITEM NUMBER 24 S S 15 DASH 20 HARVEY, C SMITH AND WR SNIFF TRACK BAT FLAG, LOT SUBDIVISION PROPOSED FLAG, LOT SUBDIVISION LOCATED SOUTH OF LEE PRICE ROAD IN WEST OF GREENLAND SPRINGS ROAD IN ITEM 25 S S 16, 20 BESSIE MILLS SAMUEL'S ESTATE LAG, LOT SUBDIVISION PROPOSED FLAG, LOT SUBDIVISION LOCATED EAST OF HIGHWAY 61 IN NORTH OF BENNETT ROAD BARNETT ROAD.
THE PLANNING COMMISSION STAFF CERTIFIES THAT ALL OF THE, THESE ISLANDS ARE CONSISTENT WITH THE CONFERENCE OF PLAN AND THE UDC COMMISSION MEMBERS.
YOU'VE HEARD ALL THE ITEMS THAT HAVE BEEN PLACED ON THE CONSENT AGENDA THAT WILL BE TAKEN WITH ONE VOTE.
ARE THERE ANY MEMBERS OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION? WE HAVE AN ITEM ON THE CONSENT THAT THEY WOULD LIKE TO BE PULLED TO BE HEARD AS PART OF THE REGULAR AGENDA.
DO WE HAVE ANY MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC PRESENT WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK ON ANY ITEMS THAT ARE ON THE CONSENT AGENDA?
WHICH ITEMS ARE THOSE? I DON'T KNOW.
AND ITEM NUMBER 12 WILL BE PULLED FROM THE, OKAY.
IS THERE A MOTION TO APPROVE THE REMAINING ITEMS ON THE CONSENT AGENDA AS A MOTION FROM COMMISSIONER ALLEN SECOND BY COMMISSIONER ADDISON, ARE THERE ANY OBJECTIONS TO APPROVING THOSE ITEMS SAYING NONE OF THOSE ITEMS HAVE BEEN APPROVED COMMISSIONED MEMBERS AT THIS TIME BEFORE WE MOVE ON, I'D LIKE TO POINT OUT TO EVERYONE WATCHING, UH, SPECIFICALLY THOSE THAT WITH, UH, ITEMS OF INTEREST ON TONIGHT'S AGENDA, THAT WE UNFORTUNATELY ONLY HAVE SIX MEMBERS OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION THAT WERE ABLE TO MAKE IT TO TONIGHT'S MEETING.
UH, HISTORICALLY, UH, WHEN THAT IS THE CASE WE HAVE THIS BODY HAS ALLOWED THE, HAS GRANTED WHEN, WHEN REQUESTED THAT THE HAS GRANTED A DEFERRAL AND AUTOMATIC DEFERRAL TO THE APPLICANTS.
AND SO WE'LL PLAN TO DO THAT, UH, TONIGHT AS WELL.
AND I'LL REMIND THE PUBLIC THAT IN THOSE INSTANCES, WHEN THE APPLICANT CHOOSES TO DEFER THEIR ITEM AND IN THIS CASE, UH, DIRECTOR HOPE I THINK WOULD BE THE PRIOR TO THE DECEMBER MEETING IS CORRECT ANY ITEM, WHICH IS THE, FOR TONIGHT AT THE AFRICANS, UH, WISHES WOULD BE PLACED ON THE REGULAR AGENDA ON DECEMBER 14.
AND SO I WILL REMIND THE PUBLIC AND THOSE WISHES WISHING TO SPEAK ON THOSE ITEMS. UH, WE TRADITIONALLY ASK THAT YOU HOLD THOSE COMMENTS TO BE HELD AT THAT SAME MEETING IN DECEMBER SO THAT THEY CAN BE CONSIDERED WHEN WE ARE, UH, WHEN WE'RE READY TO CONSIDER THE ITEM, WOULD THAT WE CAN NOW MOVE
[Items 6 & 7]
[6. PA-20-20 1885 Wooddale Boulevard]
[7. Case 56-20 1885 Wooddale Boulevard]
ON TO THE REGULAR AGENDA.MR. CHAIRMAN, THE NEXT TWO ITEMS MAY BE TAKEN TOGETHER.
THANK YOU, MR. HOLCOMB, COMMISSIONER MEMBERS WILL HEAR ITEM NUMBER SIX, PLAN AMENDMENT 2020 1-885-WOODDALE BOULEVARD AND ITEM NUMBER SEVEN, CASE 56 20 1-885-WOODDALE BOULEVARD.
WOODDALE BOULEVARD IS PROBABLY SOMEBODY ON THE WEST SIDE OF WOODDALE BOULEVARD, NORTH OF EXCHANGE PLACE.
THE COUNCIL DISTRICT SIX LEWIS.
THE APPLICANT IS SCOTT PATTERSON.
THE APPLICANT HAS PROPOSED A REZONING FROM ANYONE LIGHT INDUSTRIAL AND INTO HEAVY INDUSTRIAL TO H C1, HEAVY COMMERCIAL ONE COMMERCIAL RELATING CASE PLANNING EVENT.
THE APPLICANT IS REQUESTED TO TAKE COMPREHENSIVE LAND USE PLAN AMENDMENT FROM INSTITUTIONAL TO EMPLOYMENT CENTER CASE 56 20 WITH RELATED CASE PLANNING THEM AT 2020 1885 WITH DELVIN MCFARLANE STAFF RECOMMENDS APPROVAL OF THE PLAN AMENDMENT BASED UPON EXAMINATION OF THE AREA AT A FURTHER LEVEL OF DETAIL AND COMPATIBILITY
[00:15:01]
WITH SURROUNDING USES STAFF ALSO CERTIFIES THAT THE PROPOSED REZONING REQUEST MEETS THE CRITERIA FOR A CHANGE OF ZONING.IF THE COMPLAINT COMPANION PLAN AMENDMENT IS APPROVED, BEING CONSISTENT WITH THE CONFERENCE OF THE PLAN COMPATIBLE WITH SURROUNDING USES AND CONFORMING TO UNIFIED DEVELOPMENT CODE REQUIREMENTS, COMMISSIONER MEMBERS AT THIS TIME, I'LL OPEN THE PUBLIC HEARING THESE ITEMS. DO WE HAVE THE APPLICANT OR THE APPLICANT'S REPRESENTATIVE PRESENT WHO WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK? IF SO, PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME AND ADDRESS.
I DON'T THINK THE MICS ON GET ANYTHING GOOD.
80 PATTERSON LION'S HORSE 67 30 EXTRA HER BRA BACK ROOM LOUISIANA.
AND I'M HERE REPRESENTING THE APPLICANT AND AM AVAILABLE TO ANSWER QUESTIONS IF THERE ARE ANY, THANK YOU.
DO WE HAVE ANY OTHER MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC PRESENT AND SUPPORT WHO WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK? NO MA'AM THANK YOU.
DO WE HAVE ANY MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC PRESENT THAT ARE IN OPPOSITION THAT WISH TO SPEAK? NO MA'AM THANK YOU.
MISS YOUR MEMBERS AT THIS TIME, I'LL CLOSE THE PUBLIC HEARING AND INVITE ANY QUESTIONS, COMMENTS, OR MOTIONS FOR THESE ITEMS. COMMISSIONER ALLEN I'LL MOTION TO APPROVE.
THERE'S A MOTION ON THE FLOOR FROM COMMISSIONER ALLEN TO APPROVE THESE ITEMS. THAT MOTION HAS BEEN SECONDED BY COMMISSIONER HAWTHORNE.
ARE THERE ANY OBJECTIONS TO APPROVING THOSE ITEMS SAYING NONE OF THOSE ITEMS HAVE NOW BEEN APPROVED? MR. CHAIRMAN, WE CAN NOW MOVE
[Items 11 & 12]
[11. CONSENT FOR APPROVAL Case 57-20 7231 Innovation Park Drive]
[12. CONSENT FOR APPROVAL S-5-20 River Hills Farm]
TO THE NEXT TWO ITEMS ITEMS 11 AND 12 MAY ALSO BE TAKEN TOGETHER.AT THIS TIME, WE WILL HEAR ITEM NUMBER 11, CASE 57, 27 TO 31 INNOVATION PARK DRIVE AND ITEM NUMBER 12, SUBDIVISION FIVE 20 RIVER HILLS FARM CASE 57 20 WITH RELAY CASE SUBDIVISION FIVE 20 AT 72 31 INNOVATION, ONE IN THE NATION PARK DRIVE AS FAR NORTH OF THE NATION PARK DRIVE EAST OF NICHOLSON DRIVE COUNCIL DISTRICT THREE.
THE APPLICANT HAS PROPOSED A RESULT FROM RURAL
RESIDENTIAL FOR PROPOSED ZERO HOTLINE.
SUBDIVISION WOULD BE DRILLING.
NATION IS RESIDENTIAL NEIGHBORHOOD WHERE LADY CASE SUBDIVISION FIVE 20 RIVER HILLS FARM.
THE APPLICANT HAS BECAUSE IN 86, RESIDENTIAL LOT SUBDIVISION WITH ONE COMMON AREA TREK FOR AN OVERALL RESIDENTIAL DENSITY OF 4.46 UNITS PER ACRE TO BE ACCESS BY PUBLIC AND PRIVATE STREETS.
K SPEAKING, SEVEN 20, 72 31 INNOVATION OR DRY WITH RELATED CASE SUBDIVISION FIVE 20 RIVER HILL SPARK STAFF CERTIFIES THAT THE PROPOSED REQUEST MEETS THE CRITERIA FOR A CHANGE OF ZONING BEING CONSISTENT WITH THE CONFERENCE AND PLAN COMPATIBLE WITH SURROUNDING USES AND CONFORMING TO UNIFIED DEVELOPMENT CODE REQUIREMENTS.
ALSO CERTIFIES THAT THE PROPOSED SUBDIVISION REQUEST MEETS THE MINIMUM MINIMUM REQUIREMENTS OF THE EDC.
FOR PLANNING COMMISSION CONSIDERATION STAFF HAS RECEIVED ONE MESSAGE OF SUPPORT FOR THIS ITEM.
THANK YOU, COMMISSIONER MEMBERS AT THIS TIME, I'LL OPEN THE PUBLIC HEARING THE APPLICANT OR APPLICANT'S REPRESENTATIVE PRESENT WHO WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK.
THANK YOU, PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME AND ADDRESS ERIC DIAZ ON BEHALF OF THE APPLICANT 400 CONVENTION SUITE 1100 BEF BEFORE DENIED OR TWO APPLICATIONS.
[00:20:01]
THE FIRST APPLICATION IS A REQUEST TO REZONE FROM RURAL AND CAV TWO EIGHT, 2.6.AND THE SECOND APPLICATIONS ARE REQUESTS FOR PRELIMINARY PLAT APPROVAL OR AN 86 LOTS SUFFOCATION.
UH, BASED ON THE MAP THAT WAS BEFORE YOU JUST A MINUTE AGO, YOU'LL NOTICE THAT THE PROPERTY IS COMPLETELY SURROUNDED BY UNDEVELOPED PROPERTIES.
MOST OF THOSE PROPERTIES ARE, ARE WOODED.
AND SO, UM, WE'RE NOT AWARE OF ANY ADVERSE IMPACT ON ANY ADJOINING NEIGHBORS.
ALL OF THE WATER IN THIS CASE FLOWS AWAY FROM ANY EXISTING NEIGHBORHOODS IN THE AREA.
AND THERE'S A LARGE WOODED BUFFER BETWEEN THIS PROPERTY AND THE EXISTING HOUSES THAT THERE, THERE WAS A LAW.
IT'S A FUTURE COULOIR EXTENSION BETWEEN THE PROPERTIES UP UNTIL A FEW MINUTES AGO, WE WEREN'T AWARE OF ANY OPPOSITION.
SO I'LL LET THE OPPOSITION SPEAK ON BEHALF OF YOU ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS THAT YOU HAVE AND ADDRESS ANY ISSUES THAT IT BROUGHT UP.
DO WE HAVE ANY MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC PRESENT WHO IN SUPPORT WHO WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK? WE HAVE ONE PUBLIC AND FOR NOW I WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK AARON DOTSON, PLEASE.
AND THERE ARE NO, NO ADDITIONAL, UH, MEMBERS THAT WISH TO SPEAK IN SUPPORT, CORRECT.
ARE THERE ANY MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC WHO AND PRESENT THAT ARE IN OPPOSITION THAT WISH TO SPEAK? WE WOULD SEE THREE CARDS OF PROPOSITION THAT WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK.
PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME AND ADDRESS FOR THE RECORD.
UM, ON THE WEEKEND, UM, I'M AN OWNER OF A RENTAL PROPERTY AT 1554 LAILA STREET, BATON ROUGE, LOUISIANA SEVEN OH EIGHT TWO OH IN KENILWORTH CROSSING.
I BELIEVE IT'S LESS THAN 300 FEET AWAY FROM THE PROPOSED DEVELOPMENT.
I'VE STUDIED THAT I'VE STUDIED THE NEW DEVELOPMENT PLANS.
AND I APPRECIATE THAT THE, UH, THAT THE, THE POND OR RESERVOIRS ON THIS SLOPE OR ON THE OPPOSITE SIDE OF AMONG, UH, SUBDIVISION.
I STILL HAVE CONCERNS ABOUT FLOODING AND DRAINAGE IN THE AREA BECAUSE OUR NEIGHBORHOOD IS IN A VERY LOW LYING AREA.
AND IT, IT HAD THIS MAIN DEVELOPMENT IS, IS GOING TO BE BUILT UP AS, AS I READ, AS I THINK I READ IT WILL BE, AND I REALIZE IT WILL BE SLOWED.
I'M STILL WORRIED ABOUT WATERSHED INTO MY NEARBY PROPERTY.
DOES THAT COMPLETE YOUR COMMENT, SIR? YES.
AND THAT SPEAKER CARD, JOHN SIM, YOU STATE YOUR NAME AND ADDRESS FOR THE RECORD.
MY NAME IS JOHNSON AND I LIVE AT ONE, FIVE OR FIVE WHILE IT'S FREE.
I HAVEN'T SEEN IN TERMS OF THEIR LODGES, BUT WATERSHED THING AND WORRYING ABOUT FLOODING VIEWS ARE ALL, MOST OF THOSE HOUSES IN 2016 DID FLOOD.
AND SO ANYTIME THERE'S A LARGE RAIN, ALL THE WATER GETS UP CLOSE THE HOUSE AND YOU ARE IN THE VERY LOW AREAS AND JUST CONCERNED WITH FLOODING AND WATER AND THE POSSIBLE WRONG FROM BUILDING THE SAME ROAD.
OKAY, WELL, AND THAT'S THE FINAL SPEAKER CARD.
AT THIS TIME, I'LL INVITE THE APPLICANT BACK FOR A FIVE MINUTE REBUTTAL
[00:25:03]
MEMBERS OF THE COMMISSION.I THINK, UM, I THINK IT'S IMPORTANT FOR US TO UNDERSTAND, UM, AND THERE'S A PROCESS THAT WE ALL GO THROUGH IN ORDER TO GET SUBDIVISIONS APPROVED.
AND I CAN CERTAINLY APPRECIATE THAT MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC HAD FLOODING CONCERNS.
ONE THING TO NOTE TO UNDERSTAND IN THIS PROJECT IS THAT ALL OF THE WATER THAT IS COMING OFF OF THIS PROJECT IS GOING TO FLOW IN A NORTHWEST DIRECTION WITH ATTENTION ON, AND THEN THAT WATER WILL FLOW DIRECTLY TO ELBOW VOLUME WILL NOT FLOAT TOWARDS, UM, EACH SOUTH EAST, WHICH IS WHERE I THINK EACH OF THE, UH, MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC THAT SPOKE LIVE.
THERE'S ALSO ABOUT A HUNDRED FOOT WOODEN BUFFER BETWEEN THE SUBDIVISION WHERE THEY LIVE IN THIS PROPOSED SUBDIVISION.
SO IT DOESN'T EVEN IMMEDIATELY JOIN IT FOR SOME REASON THERE WOULD HAPPEN TO BE ANY TYPE OF BUILD UP.
THE OTHER THING THAT'S IMPORTANT TO REMEMBER IS THAT ACCORDING TO THE UNIFIED DEVELOPMENT CODE, THE CITY REQUIRES THAT THE ENGINEER'S MEASURE THE PEAK FLOW OF WATER OFF OF A PIECE OF PROPERTY, PRIVATE DEVELOPMENT.
AND THEN THEY HAVE TO MEASURE AND CERTIFY AGAIN, POST DEVELOPMENT THAT AT THE PEAK FLOW WILL NOT BE EXCEEDED.
AND SO NOT ONLY WILL THE DEVELOPERS ENGINEERS HAVE TO GO THROUGH THAT PROCESS TO CERTIFY THE TRUE GREGG, BUT THEN THE CITY'S ENGINEERS WILL LOOK AT THE CONSTRUCTION PLANS AND CERTIFIED AS WELL.
SO HOPEFULLY THAT GIVES SOME COMFORT TO THE MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC BETTER CONCERNED ABOUT, AND WE CAN CERTAINLY UNDERSTAND WHY THEY ARE.
THAT'S NOT GOING TO BE AN ISSUE.
I'LL BE HAPPY TO ANSWER ANY OTHER QUESTIONS YOU HAVE.
THANK YOU, COMMISSIONER MEMBERS AT THIS TIME, I'LL CLOSE THE PUBLIC HEARING AND INVITE ANY, ANY QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS ON THESE, ON THESE ITEMS, VICE CHAIRMAN GROUT.
THIS IS PRELIMINARY PLAT APPROVAL, CORRECT? THAT'S CORRECT.
UM, THAT BEING THE CASE, UH, I MOVED FOR APPROVAL.
THERE WAS A MOTION ON THE FLOOR FROM VICE CHAIRMAN CROP ROUTE TO APPROVE THESE ITEMS THERE.
A SECOND, SECOND FROM COMMISSIONER ADDISON, ARE THERE ANY OBJECTIONS TO APPROVING THESE ITEMS, SAY NONE OF THOSE ITEMS HAVE BEEN APPROVED COMMISSIONED MEMBERS AT THIS TIME,
[15. CONSENT FOR APPROVAL PUD-4-12 The Greens at Millerville Concept Plan Revision 11]
WE WILL MOVE ON TO ITEM NUMBER 15, PUT FOUR 12, THE GREENS AT MILLERSVILLE CONCEPT PLAN REVISION, 11 WAYNE, YOU DEVELOPMENT FOR 12.THE GREENS HAD NEVER BUILT CONCEPT PLAN REVISION 11.
THESE PROPERTIES ARE LOCATED ON THE WEST SIDE OF MILLERSVILLE ROAD AND NORTH OF INNER CITY, 12 COUNCILLOR DISTRICT, KATIE AMOROUS.
SO THE APPLICANT HAS PROPOSED TO REVISE PERMISSIBLE USES IN AREAS A B, C, N D TO INCLUDE MULTI-FAMILY RESIDENTIAL AND AN INDOOR FIRING SLASH SHOOTING RANGE WITH AN EDUCATIONAL CENTER IN CLUB, OVERALL RESIDENTIAL DENSITY OF 33.68 UNITS PER ACRE, AND THE TOTAL AMOUNT OF UNITS AT 320 ON 9.5 ACRES LIKE JULIAN USED HIS NATION IS COMMERCIAL PLANNING IN DEVELOPMENT FOR 12, THE GREENS OF VOLVO CONCEPT PLAN REVISION ELECTRIC STAFF CERTIFIES THAT THE PROPOSED WEST WILL MEET THE MINIMUM CRITERIA FOR A PLANNED UNIT DEVELOPMENT COMPATIBLE WITH SURROUNDING USES AND CONFORMING TO UNIFIED DEVELOPMENT CODE REQUIREMENTS.
OUR OFFICE RECEIVED A COUPLE EMAILS EARLIER OVER THE WEEKEND, REQUESTING ADDITIONAL INFORMATION FROM THE ADJACENT SUBDIVISION TO THE DETAILS OF THIS DEVELOPMENT.
IT WAS EXPLAINED TO THEM THAT THIS IS A CONCEPT PLAN, UH, ONLY ADDING A USE TO THE PREVIOUSLY APPROVED CONCEPT PLAN THAT A FINAL DEVELOPMENT PLAN WOULD HAVE TO BE SUBMITTED FOR A FUTURE PUBLIC HEARING BEFORE THEY WERE TO BUILD ANYTHING OR ANY FUTURE BUILDINGS WOULD BE ADDED TO THE SITE.
THANK YOU, COMMISSIONER MEMBERS AT THIS TIME, I WILL OPEN THE PUBLIC HEARING.
UH, DO WE HAVE APPLICANT OR APPLICANT'S REPRESENTATIVES PRESENT WHO WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK? I DON'T THINK THE MIC IS ON CHRIS BEARS BEARS THE ONE, 1-854-BRIXHAM AVENUE, BATON ROUGE, UH, 781 SIX.
UH, THIS IS, THIS IS PRETTY STRAIGHTFORWARD.
IT'S JUST THE CONCEPT PLAN REVISION, UM, WHICH WAS ADDING A FEW USE MULTI-FAMILY MEDICAL OFFICE.
AND THEN IN NORTH BYRON'S LEFT SHOOTING RAIN.
ACTUAL DEVELOPMENT IS PROPOSED JUST YET.
WE'LL BE DOING THAT FOR THE FINAL DEVELOPMENT PLAN.
UM, I'M HAPPY TO ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS.
DO WE HAVE ANY MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC PRESENT IN SUPPORT WHO WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK SUPPORT?
[00:30:03]
THANK YOU.DO WE HAVE ANY MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC PRESENT IN OPPOSITION WHO WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK? YEAH, NO PROBLEM.
THANK YOU, COMMISSION MEMBERS AT THIS TIME, I WILL CLOSE THE PUBLIC HEARING AND INVITE ANY QUESTIONS, COMMENTS, OR EMOTIONS FOR THIS ITEM.
I'LL MOTION TO THERE'S A MOTION ON THE FLOOR FROM COMMISSIONER ALLEN TO APPROVE THIS ITEM.
IS THERE A SECOND TO THAT MOTION? SECOND FROM COMMISSIONER ADDISON.
ARE THERE ANY OBJECTIONS TO APPROVING THIS ITEM? SAY NONE.
THAT ITEM HAS BEEN APPROVED AT THIS TIME.
[21. S-6-20 Villas at Oak Bend]
TO ITEM NUMBER 21, SUBDIVISION SIX 20 VILLAS AT OH, BEN AND SAID, OH YEAH, SUBDIVISION SIX 20 VILLAS OPEN.THIS PROPERTY IS LOCATED SOUTH OF SOUTH HARRIS FERRY ROAD AND EAST OF O'NEILL LANE COUNCIL DISTRICT NINE, HUDSON.
THE APPLICANT IS MATTHEW ROBERTSON, THE AFRICAN MR. PROSE TAKE 120 RESIDENTIAL LOT SUBDIVISION WITH THREE COMMON AREA TRACKS WHERE THE OVERALL RESIDENTIAL DENSITY OF 3.27 UNITS PER ACRE TO BE ACCESSED BY PUBLIC STREETS.
THAT FEATURE LAND USE DESIGNATION IS RESIDENTIAL NEIGHBORHOOD SUBDIVISION, SIX 20 VILLAS PLANNING STAFF CERTIFIES THAT THE PROPOSED REQUEST MEETS THE MINIMUM CRI REQUIREMENTS OF THE UDC FOR PLANNING COMMISSION CONSIDERATIONS DUE TO THE NUMBERS OF COMMISSIONERS HERE TONIGHT, PRESENT, WE HAVE RECEIVED THE REQUEST FROM THE APPLICANT WISHING TO DEFER THIS ITEM TO THE DECEMBER PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING.
DO WE HAVE THE AFGHAN HERE TO CONFIRM THAT I'LL BELIEVE THE MIX ONLINE? YES, WE CAN CONFIRM.
AS A REMINDER, IN THESE INSTANCES, WE ASKED THAT THE PUBLIC WHO WISH TO SPEAK ON THE ITEM THAT'S BEING DEFERRED, UH, WITHHOLD THEIR COMMENTS TO THE DECEMBER MEETING TO BE CONSIDERED TO BE CONSIDERED, UH, WHEN THAT ITEM IS PRESENTED, DO WE HAVE ANY MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC WHO WISH TO SPEAK ANYWAY? YES, WE DO HAVE
IT IS WORKING KIND OF GO AHEAD.
I LIVE AT THREE, TWO ONE FOUR SILVER SAND DRIVE IN CLEAR LAKE ESTATES, ADJACENT TO THE SUBDIVISION.
UM, I ASK THAT THE COUNCIL TAKE A CLOSE LOOK OR THE COMMISSION TAKE A CLOSE LOOK, RATHER AT THIS DEVELOPMENT FOR THE DENSITY AND THE NUMBER OF HOMES THAT ARE GOING TO BE PUT IN HERE.
UH, THERE'S NO QUESTION THAT THIS IS GOING TO HAVE AN ADVERSE IMPACT, NOT ONLY ON DRAINAGE AND FLOODING OF, UH, TRAFFIC AND QUALITY OF LIFE.
FOR THOSE OF US THAT LIVE IN THE, IN THE AIR, THE SUBDIVISION IS JUST TOO HIGHLY CONCENTRATED FOR THE AREA AND SHOULD BE LOOKED AT AS FAR AS THE NUMBER OF HOMES WITHIN THE DEVELOPMENT.
AND I'LL REFER TO THE REST OF MY COMMENTS TO THE NEXT MEETING
I'D LIKE TO ASK, UH, OUR LEGAL COUNSEL, UH, PAULO TO SPEAK.
I JUST WANT TO MAKE A POINT THAT THE APPLICANT IS REQUESTED A DEFERRAL AND AS A REQUEST FOR THE DEFERRAL.
AND AS A RESULT OF THAT, HE DID NOT GET AN OPPORTUNITY TO SPEAK.
SO IF ANY MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC WANT TO SPEAK, THEN THE PUBLIC HEARING WILL HAVE HAD TO HAVE OCCURRED.
AND THEN THERE WILL BE NEW OPPORTUNITY
[00:35:01]
TO THE NEXT TIME, UH, TO SPEAK.SO THIS MATTER WHAT THE PUBLIC HEARING WILL BE CONSIDERED HAD, AND THE MATTER WOULD THEN, UH, BE CLOSED, UH, TO THE NEXT TIME.
SO, UM, AT THIS POINT I WOULD, UH, CAUTION AND ANY MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC THAT IF THEY WANT TO COMMENT, THEY MAY DO SO, BUT THAT THEY WILL NOT HAVE THE OPPORTUNITY TO COME DECEMBER THE NEXT MEETING TO MAKE A COMMENT AS WELL AS THEY WOULD BE DUPLICATIVE AND NOT HAVE HAD A MICKEY TO HAVE AN OPPORTUNITY TO SPEAK.
SO JUST WANT TO MAKE THAT CRYSTAL CLEAR.
SO IF I UNDERSTAND CORRECTLY, IF THE W UNDERSTAND THAT THERE ARE MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC WHO STILL WISH TO SPEAK, UH, DESPITE, UH, EARLIER INFORMATION ON HOW WE GENERALLY ENCOURAGE PEOPLE TO HOLD, HOLD THOSE, UH, COMMENTS SO THAT THEY CAN BE CONSIDERED WHEN THE APPLICANT GIVES THIS PRESENTATION AT THE NEXT MEETING, CORRECT.
NOW THEY CHOOSE TO MOVE FORWARD WITH SPEAKING TONIGHT.
THEN THEY WON'T HAVE THAT SAME OPPORTUNITY AT THE NEXT MEETING, CORRECT? NO, IT WOULD HAVE BEEN CONSIDERED THE MATTER THE PUBLIC HEARING WOULD HAVE BEEN CONSIDERED HELD FOR THEIR COMMENTS.
SO THEY WOULD NOT BE GIVEN AN OPPORTUNITY TO SPEAK AT THAT OPPORTUNITY.
SO DO THE MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC WHO WERE WISHING TO SPEAK STILL WANT TO SPEAK TONIGHT, OR WOULD THEY PREFER TO HOLD THEIR COMMENTS UNTIL THE NEXT MEETING? WHEN THE APPLICANT GIVES THIS PRESENTATION AND WE MAKE A DECISION ON THIS ITEM, I WOULD LIKE TO SAY THAT THAT WAS NOT THE WAY IT WAS PRESENTED TO ME.
IT WAS SAD THAT WOULD ANYONE LIKE TO SPEAK ANYWAY, I WAS NOT INFORMED THAT I WOULD NOT BE ABLE TO SPEAK AT THE NEXT MEETING, OR I WOULD HAVE HELPED WITH ALL MY COMMENTS.
ARE THERE ANY OTHER MEMBERS WHO IS EVERYONE ELSE, UH, OKAY.
WITH HOLDING THEIR MEETINGS, THEIR COMMENTS TO THE NEXT MEETING ARE, DO THEY WISH TO PROCEED WITH MAKING THEIR COMMENTS TONIGHT? THANK YOU, COMMISSION MEMBERS AT THIS TIME, I WILL CLOSE PUBLIC HEARING.
I BELIEVE THE APPLICANT HAS REQUESTED TO REF TO DEFER THIS ITEM FOR 30 DAYS, UH, TO THE DECEMBER 14TH MEETING.
IS THERE A MOTION TO HONOR THEIR REQUEST? THERE WAS A MOTION FROM COMMISSIONER ADDISON SECOND FROM VICE CHAIRMAN GROUT.
ARE THERE ANY OBJECTIONS TO THAT MOTION? SAY NONE.
THAT ITEM HAS BEEN DEFERRED COMMISSION MEMBERS AT THIS TIME,
[23. SS-14-20 Alex Terrell Tract (Flag Lot Subdivision)]
WE WILL MOVE ON TO ITEM NUMBER 23, SMALL SUBDIVISION, 1420 ALEX TO RAIL TRACK, SMALL SUB DIVISION 1420 ALEX TERELLO TRENDS.AS FAR AS LOOKING AT WEST OF BALLANTINE ROAD AND SOUTH OF GERALD RIVER COUNCIL DISTRICT
THE APPLICANT HAS PROPOSED TO RESIDENTIAL WATTS WITH AN OVERALL RESIDENTIAL DENSITY OF 0.28 UNITS PER ACRE.
THEY BE CHILLING USE TO THE NATION IT'S RESIDENTIAL NEIGHBORHOOD, SMALL CELEBRATION TO 14 TO ONE ALEX JONES, CHURN STAFF CERTIFIES THAT THE PROPOSED REQUEST MEETS THE MINIMUM REQUIREMENTS OF THE UDC FOR PLANNING, COMMISSION, PLANNING, COMMISSION CONSIDERATION.
MR. CHAIRMAN MEMBERS OF THE COMMISSION.
WE HAVE RECEIVED 56 MESSAGES IN OPPOSITION TO THE SIDE.
THANK YOU, COMMISSION MEMBERS AT THIS TIME, I'LL OPEN THE PUBLIC HEARING AND WE HAVE THE APPLICANT OR THE ADVOCATE REPRESENTATIVE PRESENT WHO WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK.
PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME AND ADDRESS FOR THE RECORD.
I LIVE AT ONE EIGHT SEVEN THREE FOUR LAQUINTA AVENUE AND CENTRAL.
AND, UH, YES, THERE, OBVIOUSLY YOU GUYS HAVE, UM, RECEIVED SOME OPPOSITION TO THE PROPOSED PROJECT, AND I TRULY BELIEVE THAT THAT IS A, UM, A REPRESENTATION OF A MISUNDERSTANDING AND NOT, UH, CITIZENS NOT BEING FULLY INFORMED OF WHAT THE PROJECT HAS BEEN, UH, PRESENTED.
UH, IT'S COME TO OUR ATTENTION AS, UH, THE APPLICANT THAT, UH, THERE HAS BEEN NUMEROUS RUMORS THAT THERE IS GOING TO BE A BRIDGE SPANNING TOM'S UPSCALE, SPANNING JONES CREEK, UH, THAT THAT'S GOING TO EXTEND FROM THE END OF VALENTINE ROAD INTO THE NEW, UH, NEWLY DEVELOPED DELAROSA SUBDIVISION.
AND I DO BELIEVE THAT THAT IS WHY WE HAVE SO MUCH OPPOSITION TO, UH, TO THIS.
THERE IS NO PROPOSED BRIDGE OR CUT-THROUGH OR ANY SORT, SORT OF TURN AROUND THAT IS GOING TO BE PROPOSED AT THE END OF BALLANTINE ROAD.
UM, MY CLIENT IS PROPOSING STRICTLY TO
[00:40:01]
HAVE THE, UH, THE FORMER PORTION OF THEIR EXISTING ACREAGE SUBDIVIDED INTO A TRADITIONAL FLAG LOT, UH, FOR THE SAKE OF A SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENCE, UH, TO BE ESTABLISHED ON THAT PROPERTY ITSELF.UH, WE DO NOT BELIEVE THAT THIS, UM, THE SAME FAMILY RESIDENCE WILL PROPOSE ANY SORT OF FLOODING ISSUES TO THE AREA.
UH, PROPERTY IS LOCATED DIRECTLY ADJACENT TO JONES CREEK AND PROPERTY SLIPPED INTO JOHN'S CREEK.
THEREFORE, ALL OF THE DRAINAGE WILL PROVE ITSELF.
DO WE HAVE ANY MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC PRESIDENT SUPPORT WHO WOULD LIKE TO SPEAK? YES.
YOU HAVE TWO CARDS AND SUPPORT ONE.
WOULD I LIKE TO SPEAK DAN? YOU ARE MATHENY, PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME AND ADDRESS FOR THE RECORD.
I AM THE CO-OWNER OF THIS PROPERTY ALONG WITH MY WIFE, JANE.
WE HAVE LIVED AT THIS PROPERTY FOR 28 YEARS AND WE HAVE 7.1 ACRES IS ALSO KNOWN TO MANY PEOPLE AS SUNNY FARMS. WE DECIDED ABOUT A YEAR AGO THAT, UH, AS I APPROACH RETIREMENT AND SHE DID DO THAT, WE WANTED TO DOWNSIZE AND TO SELL A SMALL PORTION OF OUR PROPERTY AND DIVIDE IT INTO A 100 ACRE LOT, WHICH WE HAVE SUBMITTED AND HAD ALL OF THE INFORMATION PROVIDED TO THE, TO THE ZONING COMMISSION TO DO SO.
WE JUST FOUND OUT IN THE LAST, UM, WEEK OR SO ABOUT THIS, UH, OPPOSITION.
AND WE HAD NO IDEA WHEN SOMEONE APPROACHED US AND SAID, WELL, WHY ARE THEY GOING TO PUT A BRIDGE ACROSS JONES CREEK TO CONNECT TO THE BELLICOSE SUBDIVISION? WE'D HAVE NO IDEA WHERE THIS RUMOR GOT STARTED, WHO STARTED IT OR WHY THEY DID, BUT WE HAVE NEVER HAD ANY ATTENTION OR PLANS TO DO SO.
AND IT SEEMS FROM ALL THE LETTERS THAT WE'VE READ WITH THE EXCEPTION OF ONE NEIGHBOR ON VALENTINE ROAD WAS CONCERNED ABOUT DRAINAGE, THAT EVERY SINGLE BIT OF OPPOSITION HAS BEEN TO THE BRIDGE ACROSS JONES CREEK ROAD, THE NON-EXISTENT BRIDGE, AND TAKING THAT BRIDGE AND, AND SETTING UP ACCESS INTO WOODLAND RIDGE, UH, MILLBORO SUBDIVISIONS AND OTHER ADJACENT SUBDIVISION, ALL OF THE WAY, ALL OF WHICH IS FALLS.
AND ALL OF IT IS BASED UPON A RUBRIC, WHICH WE'VE NEVER BEEN ABLE TO DETERMINE WHO STARTED IT.
BUT, UM, IN ESSENCE, WE'RE JUST TRYING TO TAKE AN ACRE AND A HALF PIECE OF OUR PROPERTY SUBDIVIDED AND SELL IT WITH NO CHANGE WHATSOEVER TO THE PROPERTY.
DON'T CHANGE TO THE DRAINAGE, NO CHANGE TO, UH, NO DRIVE OR ROAD INTERSECTING.
SO WE REQUEST THAT YOU ALL TAKE THAT INTO CONSIDERATION AND, UM, AND ALLOW US TO BE ABLE TO JUST DO A SIMPLE SUBDIVIDE OUR PROPERTY OF WHICH WE HAVE 7.1 ACRES, AND WE ONLY WANT TO SUBDIVIDE 1.5 ACRE OF THIS INTO THE REQUIRED FLAG LOT.
ADD SOMETHING TO PUT ON THE BOTTLE.
ONE OF THE THINGS WE WOULD LIKE TO ADD TO THIS, UH, PRIOR CONSIDERATION, I'M SORRY.
I'M GOING TO HAVE TO STOP YOU RIGHT THERE.
WE'LL NEED TO HEAR THE REMAINDER OF THE SPEAKER CARDS AND YOU'LL HAVE OPPORTUNITY TO PRESENT ANY ADDITIONAL INFORMATION IN YOUR REBUTTAL.
THAT WAS AT THE PUBLIC SPEED OUT INTO FOUR.
ANY MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC AND OPPOSITION WHO WISH TO SPEAK?
UM, MY NAME IS JEANETTE AND USE BOMBER.
THE ADDRESS IS 38 33 VALENTINE ROAD.
IT'S RIGHT ACROSS FROM THE PROPERTY.
THAT'S SOMETHING YOU'D BE SUBDIVIDED.
MY CONCERNS ARE PROPERTY VALUE.
[00:45:01]
THE MAJORITY OF THE PROPERTY THAT IS ON VALENTINE ROAD OFF COMES OFF NUMEROUS EIGHTH BRIDGE LIGHTS.THEY SAID BEFORE, THERE'S A SEVEN ACRES MINE ACROSS THE STREET AT EIGHT ACRES.
THE ONE NEXT TO THEM IS ABOUT THE SAME AMOUNT OF ACREAGE.
UM, IF THEY SPLIT THAT UP AND MAKE IT LIKE A ONE ACRE AND A HALF POT, THAT'S GOING TO CHANGE THE VALUE OF MY HOUSE AND CHANGE THE VALUE OF OTHERS THAT LIVE ON THAT STREET TOO.
WHY DON'T WE TALK ABOUT FLOODING WHEN WE HAVE THE FLAG, THE PROPERTY THAT IS IN QUESTION THAT APRIL, THAT IS IN PR IN QUESTION ABOUT BUILDING WAS COMPLETELY UNDERWATER.
THE ANIMALS FROM THE FARM HAD TO BE REMOVED FOR THEIR SAFETY.
IF YOU LOOK AT THE PROPERTY THAT TO BE SOLD, IT GOES OVER, JUMPED CREEP.
SO ANYTHING THAT HAPPENS TO THAT PROPERTY AS IN BUILDING A NEW HOUSE IS GOING TO BE A JONES CREEK WILL BE AFFECTED BY IT.
I HAVE HAD DRAINAGE PROBLEMS SINCE THE FLOOD, THE FLOOD, THE WATER NOW WHILE THE WATER USED TO DRAIN FROM LIKE THERE, UM, THE PROPERTY IN QUESTION, OH, WORK USED TO DRINK OVER EIGHT DRINKS OVER TO MY HOUSE.
AND THEN DOWN INTO THE SMALL SUBDIVISION THAT IS IN THE BACK OF MY EIGHT ACRE PROPERTY UP UNTIL A COUPLE OF MONTHS AGO, WHERE WE HAD TO PAY THOUSANDS OF DOLLARS TO GET IT RETRAINED SO THAT A DRAIN PROPERLY AND THAT IT DIDN'T DRAIN INTO THE NEIGHBORHOOD AND THAT IT DRAINED BACK TO JONES CREEK.
SO I DEALT WITH THAT SINCE THE FLOOD, BECAUSE WHEN THE FLOOD HAPPENED, ALL THE WATER GOT MESSED UP.
AND I BELIEVE THAT IF YOU ALLOW SOMEBODY TO GO IN AND THEY HAVE TO REBUILD THAT THE HOUSE, IT TOLD OUT PROPER JANE DRAINAGE, IT'S GOING TO AFFECT DRAIN ON MY PROPERTY, WHICH IS GOING TO DRAIN ON THE NEIGHBORHOOD PROPERTY THAT'S BEHIND ME.
I JUST WANT TO LET YOU TELL YOU HAVE ABOUT 25 SECONDS ISSUE, WHICH I'VE HEARD B CURRENTLY HAVE IT FIXED.
SO IT GOES INTO JOHN'S CREEK AND NOT THE NEIGHBORHOOD BEHIND US, BUT I'LL SAY IT AGAIN.
IF THERE'S ANY OTHER CHANGE, LIKE I CROSSED THE STREET, ALL THAT WATER IS GOING TO GET SHIFTED BACK ONTO ME, WHICH IS GOING TO GET SHIFTED BACK ONTO THE PROPERTIES BEHIND ME, WHICH ARE LITTLE CUTE GARDEN HOME.
OCCASIONAL IS A LID ON A VERY ELIZABETH JOB ON THE RESTAURANT SHENANDOAH HILLS SUBDIVISION.
UH, I'M IN LA OPPOSITION TO THIS BECAUSE OF THE PREVIOUS COMMENTS FROM THE OWNER.
UH, AND FOR ME ALSO, THE FACT THAT WE FLOODED IN 2016 AND HAVE NOT STOPPED RAINWATER, CONTINUE TO COME INTO BARRIER LIST WITH JOB OFF VALENTINE.
I'M CONCERNED ABOUT IN OTHER DEVELOPMENT AND ALLOW ON A SUBDIVISION OF THIS LOCK, UH, OR THIS, HER PROPERTY RIGHT NOW, OR THEIR PROPERTY.
WHAT CONTINUE DOWN THE LINE OF VALENTINE AND WHAT ALTER THE WHOLE LANDSCAPE HERE.
WE'RE TALKING ABOUT ROLL STREET AND YOU CAN WALK DOWN AND NOT GET HIT BY TRAFFIC, AS OPPOSED TO MARY ELIZABETH, EVERYONE I'VE TALKED TO ON VALENTINE.
EVERYONE I'VE TALKED TO AND SHENANDOAH HILLS HAS NO IDEA ABOUT, OR NO RUMOR ABOUT A BRIDGE.
THE OPPOSITION IS TO THE REZONING.
WE WOULD OBVIOUSLY BE AN OPPOSITION THAT THE BRIDGE WAS PART OF THIS.
SO JUST KEEP THAT IN MIND, THE BULK OF THE OPPOSITION HAS NOTHING TO DO WITH RUMOR BRIDGE.
IT HAS TO DO WITH REZONING THIS LOT AND CAUSING FLOODING ON MARRIED TO ELIZABETH AND SOLIDAD, WHICH I BELIEVE, UH, FLOODED 10 HOUSES DOWNPLAYED.
UM, SO, UH, AS, AGAIN, AS A PREVIOUS PAPER SAID, THIS IS GOING
[00:50:01]
TO AGGRAVATE OTHER FLOODING WITHIN OUR NEIGHBORHOOD, PUSH IT ON TO US.YOU CAN MITIGATE ALL YOU CLAIM.
YOU WILL DO WHAT WE'VE SEEN, WHAT HAPPENED TO BELLA COSA AND ONE THAT IS GOING TO DO TO US.
IF WE HAVE DEVELOPMENT IN OUR AREA, WE DID NOT GET FLOODED.
AND JUST ONE AREA, WE GOT FLOODING FROM THE NORTH, THE WEST AND THE SOUTH, AND BELIEVE IT OR NOT CAME FROM THE EAST TOO, BECAUSE ONCE THE WATER GETS INTO THE SEWER DRAINS OR THE STORM PAINS, IT COMES UP IN FRONT OF MY MAPLEWOOD AND WATER LINE AND DEBRIS LINE HIT MY GARAGE.
I DO NOT WISH THAT THERE'S A REZONING OCCURS BASED ON THAT FACT.
ARE THERE ANY ADDITIONAL SPEAKER CARDS? OKAY.
YOU STATE YOUR NAME AND ADDRESS FOR THE RECORDS? WELL, MY ADDRESS IS 37 51 VALENTINE ROAD.
I HAD PROPERTY AT 38, 13 VALENTINE ON THE POST OF THIS UNTIL PROPER DRAINAGE IS TAKEN CARE OF IN THAT AREA.
I CANNOT GO THROUGH ANOTHER FLOOD.
I WAS THERE AND I LIVE ON VALENTINE BROTHER, FATHER, 50 YEARS.
I'VE DONE THAT AND NOT SEEING THAT.
IF THERE ARE NO MORE SECRET CARDS, I'D LIKE TO INVITE THE APPLICANT BACK FOR FIVE MINUTES.
UM, WE UNDERSTAND THAT THE MAJORITY OF, UH, SUPPORT OR LACK OF SUPPORT IS FLOATING AND, UM, THAT IS UNDERSTANDABLE AT THE 2016, UH, BASED ON WHAT HAPPENED.
NOW, I WOULD PETITION YOU TO CONSIDER 2016 VERSUS ANY OTHER TIMES, THERE HAS NEVER BEEN IN ANOTHER SITUATION WHERE THIS PARTICULAR BOTTLE ON BALANCE ON HAS BEEN COVERED IN WATER, AS OPPOSED TO 2016.
UM, THAT BEING SAID, YES, THERE ARE ANIMALS THAT LIVE ON THE LOT THAT DID HAVE TO BE REMOVED IN 2016.
AND TO ADDRESS THAT, UH, AS YOU SURVEYED A LOT FROM THE END OF THE STREET ON VALENTINE TO CLEARLY ADDRESS ARM REAR PORTION OF PROPERTY, THERE IS A SUBSTANTIAL, I WOULD SAY THREE, FOUR OR FIVE FOOT OF DROP IN ELEVATION.
IT'S VERY EVIDENT AND VERY OBVIOUS, THEREFORE REASONING TO WHY THE ANIMALS HAD TO BE, UH, REMOVED FROM THAT PROPERTY TO BE KNOW, TO REMOVE THAT.
UM, AS FAR AS, UH, WHAT I WAS GOING TO SAY A MINUTE AGO, IF YOU LOOK AT THE HISTORY OF BALLANTINE ROAD AND GO WITH THE PLAT MAPS, YOU CAN CLEARLY SEE THAT OVER THE COURSE, THE COURSE OF TIME, THERE HAS BEEN NUMEROUS BLACK LOTS, UM, FROM ONE END OF DOWNTOWN OR TO THE OTHER THAT HAPPENED INCORPORATED ONE TO, UH, AND, AND APPROVED OVER THE YEARS.
UM, SO I, I DON'T SEE WHERE THERE IS A CONCERN OF THE DIFFERENT SIDE OF THE ACREAGE BEING AN EFFECT ON THE PROPERTY VALUE.
AND AS A LICENSED REALTOR IN THE SAY OF THESE, YOU KNOW, THE SIZE OF THE EIGHT BRIDGE FROM A SEVEN ACRE TRACK TO A ONE AND A HALF ACRE TRACK WILL NOT BE A DETRIMENT TO THE ACTUAL VALUE OF THE PROPERTIES.
THEREFORE, YOU KNOW, THEY WILL BE CONSIDERED DIFFERENTLY.
OBVIOUSLY THEY'RE DIFFERENT SIZES AND B WILL BE ASSESSED AS SUCH AND WILL BE VALUED SUCH.
UM, AS FAR AS THE EFFECT, THIS WILL HAVE ON JONES FOR YOURSELF, UM, THERE WILL BE NO EFFECT DIRECTLY ON THOMAS WAS CREEK.
THE BILLABLE AREA THAT IS EXISTENCE IS EXISTENCE IS AN EXCESS OF OVER HALF AN ACRE.
AND SO THERE WILL BE NO RENOVATIONS OR NO KIND OF STRUCTURAL MOVEMENT THAT NEEDS TO TAKE PLACE ON THE CREEK ITSELF.
UM, OBVIOUSLY THAT IS SOMETHING THAT IS A, UH, MAJOR DRAINAGE AVENUE FOR MUCH OF BACK ROOMS IN ANY KIND OF, UH, ALTERING OR CHANGING OF JOHN'S PRE WILL HAVE TO BE APPROVED FIRST, ALL THE ARMY CORPS OF ENGINEERS, UH, BEFORE ANYTHING WILL BE ABLE TO BE DONE, UH, TO ADDRESS THE GENTLEMAN THAT LIVES ON MARRIOTT ELIZABETH.
UM, I UNDERSTAND THAT THERE HAD SOME FLOODING ON MARY ELIZABETH AND THE SUBDIVISION IN WHICH HE LIVES, UH, IN 2016.
MY, UH, REBUTTAL TO THAT WILL BE WHERE MARY ELIZABETH IS LOCATED IS SIGNIFICANTLY DOWN THE STREET FROM WHERE THIS LIFE IS LOCATED.
AND LIKE I SAID EARLIER, THE LOT ITSELF
[00:55:01]
DRAINS DIRECTLY IN THE DUMPSTER ORDERS DOWN THE STREET.IN FACT, PART OF A LOT IS CONSIDERED JONES CREEK.
UM, SO I WOULD, UH, I WOULD PETITION YOU TO, TO CONSIDER ALL THAT AND TO LOOK AT THAT THIS ONE LOT, ALTHOUGH APPEARS TO HAVE A SIGNIFICANT AMOUNT OF, UM, UH, YOU KNOW, OPPOSITION NOT PRESENT.
OBVIOUSLY WE HAVE A SITE WHERE PEOPLE THAT ARE HERE, UM, BUT THERE IS EVERYONE I SPOKE TO TODAY REGARDING THE MILLBROOK SUBDIVISION AGENT WITH PRESIDENT AND ALSO THE, UH, OTHER SUBDIVISION PRESIDENTS THAT ARE NEARBY.
ALL THE BIGGEST QUESTION THEY HAD WAS ABOUT A BRIDGE THAT WAS IN THE PROCESS OF BEING BUILT.
I DON'T KNOW WHERE THAT STARTED AS, AS MY CLIENT WAS THE THING, UM, MENTIONED.
AND SO AT LEAST I A CONSIDERATION AS TO WHY SUCH STRONG OPPOSITION TO THIS SONATA, THERE WAS A POSTMATE ON, UM, THE, UH, NEXT DOOR WEBSITE TODAY BY BOTH OF THOSE HOA PRESIDENTS REQUESTING IMMEDIATE ACTION, GO BACK AND LOOK AT THE POST.
UM, AND I THINK THAT'S WHY THERE WAS SUCH A STRONG EMAIL TURNOUT.
THANK YOU COMMISSIONER MEMBERS AT THIS TIME, I WILL CLOSE THE PUBLIC HEARING AND INVITE ANY QUESTIONS, COMMENTS, UH, VICE CHAIRMAN GRUPP.
I, AS A TOLD A LOT OF PEOPLE WHO KNOW ME, UH, I READ THE EMAILS AND THE EMAILS ON THIS, UH, THIS CASE, UH, BLEW UP VERY QUICKLY AND ALMOST TO A PERSON THE EMAILS HAD TO DO WITH DON'T LET, UH, DON'T LET VALENTINE BECOME A THROUGH STREET, STOP THE BRIDGE, STOP THE BRIDGE.
WE DON'T WANT TO BRIDGE, UH, I DON'T KNOW WHERE THAT CAME FROM.
IT HAS NOTHING TO DO WITH THIS, WITH THIS, UH, THIS CASE.
UH, I ALSO WAS LOOKING, SOMEONE'S TALKING ABOUT THE SIZE OF LOTS.
IF YOU GO DOWN VALENTINE ROAD, LOTS NINE, EIGHT, EIGHT, EIGHT, EIGHT, BRAVO, ONE ALPHA ALL ARE THAT SIZE OR SMALLER.
AND THERE WERE ALSO FLAGGED LOTS.
SO THERE IS PRECEDENT FOR THIS.
I ALSO, UM, LOOKED AT THE, AT THE, UH, THE CONTOUR MAP AND YES, THIS FLOWS STRAIGHT INTO JONES CREEK.
SO WHAT IT'S GOING TO DO TO OTHER PROPERTIES, I DON'T THINK IT'LL HAVE ANYTHING TO DO WITH THAT AT ALL.
AND AGAIN, 2016 WAS AN OUTLIER AND WE NEED TO REMEMBER THAT IT IS SOMETHING WE NEED TO PREPARE FOR, BUT IT'S NOT SOMETHING THAT WE NEED TO STOP THE WORLD WAR.
AND THE LAST THING I'M GOING TO SAY IS IF YOU BELIEVE ANYTHING ON NEXT DOOR, I GOT A BRIDGE TO SELL YOU, BUT IT'S NOT AFFILIATED WITH THIS PROPERTY.
I'LL PUT IT WHEREVER YOU WANT.
ARE THERE ANY ADDITIONAL COMMENTS OR QUESTIONS ON THIS ITEM? COMMISSIONER HILL? YES.
IF I GOT TO ASK MR. HOLCOMB TO, TO REALLY SPEAK TO WHAT CAN BE DONE ON A RESIDENTIAL, NOT RESIDENTIAL IN A RURAL AREA, WHAT KIND OF DEVELOPMENT COULD POTENTIALLY TAKE PLACE ON THIS LOT? IF SO, COMMISSIONER HILL, THE PROPOSAL THAT'S BEFORE YOU DECEIVED ME WOULD BE FOR ONE ADDITIONAL SINGLE FAMILY HOME.
UM, THEY'RE SPECIFICALLY REQUESTING ONE ADDITIONAL LOT.
THERE'S BEEN A LOT OF DISCUSSION ABOUT A PROPOSED BRIDGE OR A PROPOSED ACCESS STREET TO AN ADJACENT NEIGHBORHOOD.
I CAN TELL YOU THAT THAT WOULD REQUIRE A DEDICATION.
THERE IS NO DEDICATION OF A PUBLIC OR PRIVATE STREET TO THE PROPERTY LINE HERE, SO THAT WILL NOT TAKE PLACE, UM, THAT WOULD REQUIRE ADDITIONAL PUBLIC HEARING.
AND IT'S, IT'S NOT SHOWN ON THIS PLAT.
SO THE ONLY DEVELOPMENT RIGHTS ON THE PROPOSAL THAT'S BEFORE YOU TONIGHT WOULD BE ONE ADDITIONAL LOT FOR ONE ADDITIONAL SINGLE FAMILY, HOME, ADDITIONAL QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS, ANY MOTIONS, MOTION TO APPROVE AS A MOTION MOTION FROM VICE CHAIRMAN GROUT TO APPROVE HIS ITEM.
IS THERE A SECOND TO THAT MOTION? AND THERE'S A SECOND FROM COMMISSIONER ADDISON.
ARE THERE ANY OBJECTIONS TO APPROVING THIS ITEM SAYING NONE THAT ITEM HAS BEEN APPROVED
[DIRECTOR'S COMMENTS]
COMMISSION MEMBERS AT THIS TIME, WE WILL MOVE ON TO COMMUNICATIONS, UH, BEGINNING WITH THE DIRECTOR'S COMMENTS.THANK YOU, MR. CHAIRMAN MEMBERS OF THE COMMISSION, WE RECEIVED ADDITIONAL COMMENTS ON THE PROPOSED REVISIONS TO CHAPTER 16, WHICH IS ASSIGNED CHAPTER AND THE UDC STAFF IS WORKING WITH THE DEPARTMENT OF DEVELOPMENT TO ADDRESS AN APPROPRIATE PERIOD OF TIME FOR TEMPORARY SIGNS.
THIS TEXT AMENDMENT WILL BE ON A FUTURE AGENDA ONCE THE ISSUES ARE ADDRESSED.
[01:00:01]
YOU THAT THE OFFICE OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION WILL BE CLOSED ON THURSDAY AND FRIDAY, NOVEMBER 26TH AND 27TH IN OBSERVANCE OF THE THANKSGIVING HOLIDAY STAFF WOULD LIKE TO WHISK COMMISSIONER STERLING AND COMMISSIONER ISLANDER OR BELATED HAPPY BIRTHDAY, BOTH CELEBRATED BIRTHDAYS THIS PAST WEEK.WANT TO REMIND YOU THAT YOUR NEXT MEETING OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION IS SCHEDULED FOR DECEMBER 14TH.
IT WILL PROVE TO BE A LONGER MEETING THAN TONIGHT.
AND FINALLY, I'M HAPPY TO SHARE WITH YOU THAT GUILT MORIN HAS BEEN PROMOTED TO ASSISTANT PLANNING DIRECTOR.
JILL HAS WORKED AT THE PLANNING COMMISSION FOR OVER 17 YEARS AND IS BOTH THE AICP CERTIFIED PLANNER AND ALSO A CERTIFIED FLOOD PLAIN MANAGER.
JOIN ME AND CONGRATULATE AND GIVE
[COMMISSIONERS' COMMENTS]
MOVE ON TO THE COMMISSIONER'S COMMENTS AND I'LL, UH, ECHO THE SENTIMENT FROM, UH, DIRECTOR HOKUM.UH, GIL, UH, HAS BEEN A PLEASURE TO WORK WITH, UH, IN MY SEVERAL YEARS ON THIS, UH, PLANNING COMMISSION.
I'LL LOOK FORWARD TO CONTINUING TO WORK WITH YOU AND YOUR NEW CAPACITY AS ASSISTANT PLANNING, DIRECTOR GIL.
DO YOU HAVE ANYTHING ELSE THAT YOU'D LIKE TO ADD? I DON'T WANT TO PUT YOU ON THE SPOT, ANYTHING.
I THINK WE ALL LOOK FORWARD TO WORKING WITH YOU, MAN.
I'D ALSO LIKE TO CONGRATULATE OUR EMPLOYEE OF THE MONTH VANCE BALDWIN, WHO WAS THE PLANNING MANAGER AND THE SITE PLAN AND PLANT DIVISION.
IN ADDITION TO VANCE'S REGULAR WORKLOAD, HE'S ACCEPTED ATTIC DUTIES AND RESPONSIBILITIES THIS MONTH WITH OTHER EMPLOYEES BEING OUT OF THE OFFICE.
VANCE HAS COORDINATED THE ADVERTISEMENTS FOR OUR PUBLIC HEARINGS AND PREPARE THE PRELIMINARY AGENDA, ENSURING THAT IT WAS POSTED TO THE WEB IN A TIMELY MANNER FOR THE PUBLIC.
FOR THESE REASONS VANCE WAS SELECTED AS EMPLOYEE OF THE MONTH.
ARE THERE ANY ADDITIONAL COMMENTS, IF NOT, IS THERE A MOTION TO ADJOURN MOTION FROM COMMISSIONER ADDISON SECOND FROM VICE CHAIRMAN GROWLER, ANY OBJECTIONS SEEING NONE? THE MEETING'S ADJOURNED.
THANK YOU ALL SO MUCH AND HAVE A GREAT EVENING.